J.J. on Jar Jar: Why?

The brilliant Vanity Fair article this week has given us a lot of scoops. Not only do we have names for two more characters, we also got some great interviews and behind-the-scenes photos. VF also sat down with J.J. Abrams, director of upcoming The Force Awakens, for an interview and unfortunately he once again catered to the so-called ‘prequel haters’ by discussing Jar Jar Binks. Talking to VF editor Bruce Handy, Abrams said:

“I have a thought about putting Jar Jar Binks’s bones in the desert [of Jakku]. I’m serious! Only three people will notice, but they’ll love it.”

Now, I’m all for jokes. I love jokes. However, Jar Jar Binks is a very controversial figure within the Star Wars-fandom. Many fans of the Original Trilogy use him as their favourite stick to bash the Prequel Trilogy with, arguing he is a ridiculous figure, disgraceful and not worthy of being in a Star Wars-film. It has come to the point where saying that you like Jar Jar, like I do, means you have to face a barrage of disagreement, if not abuse. The fact that the same things were originally held against the Ewoks in the OT is conveniently forgotten. Everyone is allowed their own opinion and you don’t have to like everything about Star Wars. Whether you like both the OT and PT or just one of them, you have a right to liking or disliking things. However, as I have previously argued, the disproportionate hate against the PT has led to many of its good points and layers of depth to go completely unnoticed. There is more to the figure of Jar Jar than most people acknowledge and I will be going into it below.

We’re first introduced to Jar Jar on the planet Naboo when Qui-Gon Jinn and Obi-Wan Kenobi have to escape the Trade Federation’s ship after failing at initiating negotiations with them. Jar Jar has been exiled by his community of Gungans because, in his own words, he is clumsy. As such, he is an outcast who has to survive on his own and seems to have done relatively fine so far. There are a few interesting parallels to Anakin, but this is not the place to go into those. The Gungans seem to be the native inhabitants of Naboo, closely linked with nature and keeping their distance from the urban population.The humans of Naboo don’t really interact with them and there seem to be a lot of prejudices about them. Even Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan can’t help but be slightly dismissive of Jar Jar, not quite trusting him or really enjoying his presence. Lucas has been accused of making Jar Jar a racist caricature of a black Carribbean stereotype, which both he and Ahmed Best (the actor behind Jar Jar) deny. Personally, I believe that to a certain extent the stereotypes are there, but for a different purpose than you might imagine.

In the PT, Lucas presents us with the downfall of a Republic built on the principles of justice and equality. There is a clear divide between the Inner and Outer Rim with poverty in the latter and prosperity in the former, etc. Naboo seems to be a peaceful planet with a very democratic system of electing queens who are passionate about their planet. However, Lucas shows that even this planet has questionable sides. The Gungans are largely ignored and not even thought about during the invasion. They are a minority on their planet and are marginalized. Their different way of speech is interpreted by most as lack of intelligence. Qui-Gon Jinn himself says:

‘The ability to speak does not make you intelligent.’

Qui-Gon is showing himself to be rather ignorant here. Jar Jar just argued that he owed him a life-debt that is demanded by the Gods, showing himself to come from a very different culture than Qui-Gon. Jar Jar continues to live by the code of his people, despite them having kicked him out. He helps Qui-Gon unquestioningly in all his endeavours, taking him to Gungan City despite it not being allowed, following him to a planet largely made up of desert and going into battle in order to give him a chance to capture Nute Gunray. He is willing to sacrifice himself for those he cares about and never does anything unkind. He can be silly and clumsy, but is never evil. Throughout The Phantom Menace we see him trying his hardest and helping where he can. He is rewarded for his efforts with becoming a general in the Gungan army and in The Attack of the Clones he has become a part of Amidala’s team in the Senate.

Amidala’s relationship with Jar Jar is deserving of a whole post itself, since she is the only one who seems to be open to him and can see what he is worth. Her turning to him for help shows her genius as a political figure since she realizes her planet needs all of its people to come together in order to defend itself. The screencap below is a great example of how Lucas visualised this decision. When the political system fails her, she realizes she needs to turn to those who have been let down by it as well. By uniting with the Gungans she is able to free Naboo and build relations between the two groups. Jar Jar’s presence in her senatorial team shows that together they are actively working on improving those relations and giving everyone a chance at equal representation. 

The extremes of Jar Jar’s character are, at least partially I believe, there to show how the Republic and its people are flawed. Unlike any character, he triggers responses and this is because he doesn’t fit into what most people (the majority secure in its position and power) expect and therefore he is ridiculed. His characteristics are exaggerated, his intentions are misinterpreted and he is repeatedly marginalized despite his best intentions. Not many directors dare include characters that are so controversial because they also lay bare questionable attitudes within the fandom.

Star Wars is supposed to be about inclusion. We have species from all the different planets,  repeatedly coming together to fight for the right cause together. What I have seen from the cast and story-line of The Force Awakens, this film will continue that tradition. I found it very disappointing to see that J.J., rather than focusing on being inclusive, catered to the side of the fandom who refuse to interpret the PT, to really look at it and see the depth of interpretation that is has to offer. Although you can dislike a character, to say you want to display their bare bones for some people’s enjoyment may be taking it a bit far. Jar Jar isn’t half as bad as some like to shout. In the end much of the hate against Jar Jar is down to OT fans being disappointed the PT wasn’t exactly what they had imagined. J.J. Abrams has to be careful in pushing this rift in the fandom, because his own film may just be the cause for another.

10 thoughts on “J.J. on Jar Jar: Why?

  1. WELL SAID! Yousa are wonderful and brilliant! =D This makes me think more about the character than I have before, and I have put a lot of thought into the character (in an essay for my picture “Poor Jar Jar”) & have taken thoughts into consideration ( Hard Truths: Jar Jar vs Chewbacca). Plus, I really liked that last sentence about Abrams.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Jar Jar is my favorite Star Wars character. I loved him for the awesome design and slapstick antics when I first saw him at 13, but only recently have I realized he’s really my favorite.

    It’s when I really understood that, if I was in Star Wars, I would be more like Jar Jar than anyone else. When I was young, and in some ways even still today, I really was “That Guy”. I was the guy who just wanted to do his own thing and do right by everyone else, but always seemed to make things worse and generally annoy everyone I met. Every time I see Jar Jar now, I just want to give him a big hug.

    Oh, and FYI, the answer to any and all “Who would win in a fight” hypotheticals where Jar Jar is involved is “Jar Jar wins completely by accident.”


  3. You nailed it. I’ve said it many times how The Phantom Menace is a film about, first and foremost, respect. And to acknowledgment of the fact that everybody has its value. And yet the bashing only proves how relevant that movie and its message continues to be.


  4. thank you for this post. i loved Jar Jar when i first saw him in TPM as well. in actuality the TPM was my first Star Wars movie. I love the PT more than anything and find the OT to be kinda lacking, in all honesty. i love anything Star Wars though, just more the PT era.

    There is one thing everything neglects to mention about Jar Jar though…indirectly he is responsible for the Palpatine gaining control of the Clone Army and the inevitable downfall of the Republic and therefore Rise of the Empire. During AOTC Palpatine and Mas Amedda talking in front of Jar Jar about the Clone Army that and asking what Padme would do about the situation if she were there.

    During the scene the movie pans to Jar Jar who looks to be wrestling with what he should do since he is the Representative for Naboo in Padme’s absence. When Mace and Yoda are in the Senate Jar Jar is asking that Emergency Powers be handed to Palpatine to stop the droid army. that is when Palpatine says he will create a Grand Army of the Republic to fight the Separatists. Basically therefore giving Palpatine everything he needs to rule the Galaxy.

    i argue this all the time when people bring up their hate for the PT. but in all actuality there would be no OT without the PT. i do also find that JJ as well as Katherine Kennedy and Disney are all trying to disregard the PT act as if it hasn’t happened. there have been threads on iMDB about Kennedy saying she would be all for Remaking the PT. it is evident that JJ doesn’t want anything to with any of the groundwork laid out by the PT and instead wants to bring the focus back on the OT. this can be seen in everything now from Marketing to how the EU with everything PT related and pre-PT have been thrown out, to how he wants to bring back the OT cast for the newest film. It would be nice to see a nod to the PT with the Senate or Coruscant or something at least. but i doubt he would want to do that. i hope that the new film does well, but the more i keep reading about it and the way JJ as well as Disney and Kennedy are handling things now that George Lucas has left, is disheartening to say the least.


    1. I completely agree with you that the prequels are crucial to understanding all of Star Wars! They contribute so much in the sense of story background, details, themes etc. I do hope that Kathleen Kennedy and JJ are currently simply catering to a particular part of the fandom in order to get them on board, since they’re most likely to be the ones complaining after TFA comes out! Thanks for your insightful comment 🙂 – Juli

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Most of the commenters are not old enough to understand the ramifications of this terrible stereotype. The minute I first saw and heard this character of Jar Jar, I was extremely offended and embarrassed. The body language, behavior & speech instantly reminded me of a sitcom character in the 70’s called JJ on a TV show named Goodtimes. If you ever saw the character on that show, you would think they were twins. Interestingly, they also share the same initials of JJ. It was degrading Uncle Tom stereotyping & Lucas is old enough to know better. There were only 3 TV channels back then so it would have been hard for him to miss.
    It was only after the original mini-series Roots, that people realised how terrible these stereotypes were and started treating everyone with respect & dignity.
    I don’t think anyone is bashing episode one. They were bashing the offensive stereotype portrayal of an Uncle Tom character. It is racist. Many black actors thought they had to behave like that to get work. Remember Prissy on Gone with the Wind?
    If I, as a caucasian am offended, imagine how they feel. I had a spouse who didn’t know the things he joked about were wrong. His black crew members nervously laughed at his jokes to break any tension & my spouse took that as approval. I had to re-educate him & remind him as a manager, it was inappropriate & how to treat his employees with respect. I’m happy to say I was able to wash away 40 years of his bad upbringing in Oklahoma. He never did so again. Moving to California helped.
    While most viewers are too young to know how it was, Lucas has no excuse & should have known better. This wasn’t a minstrel show on Vaudeville.
    BTW, WordPress is free.


  6. Anyone has the right to dislike Jar Jar, as they do any other character, but I find all this abuse he receives very disturbing. I doubt anyone would do that of one of the Ewoks or Rey or Rose Tico or any other unpopular character (and note how many unpopular Star Wars characters J.J. invented himself). And obsession with killing the poor Gungan (who, let’s be honest, is one of the kindest people in the saga) just unsettles me.

    Also, if, the moment you get the rights to an intellectual property, you kill off the creator’s own self-professed favorite character, it does not bode well for you.


  7. Anyone has the right to dislike Jar Jar, as they do any other character, but I find all this abuse he receives very disturbing. I doubt anyone would do that of one of the Ewoks or Rey or Rose Tico or any other unpopular character (and note how many unpopular Star Wars characters J.J. invented himself). And obsession with killing the poor Gungan (who, let’s be honest, is one of the kindest people in the saga) just unsettles me.

    Also, if, the moment you get the rights to an intellectual property, you kill off the creator’s own self-professed favorite character, it does not bode well for you.


Leave a Reply to JuliWitte Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s